———————————————————————————————————————————————

20 November, 2011

What a Shame; What a Price

Christopher Booker, of The Sunday Telegraph, explains, in “The BBC’s hidden ‘warmist’ agenda is rapidly unravelling”, that the biassed BBC still sticks with its awarmist agenda even when slightly more honest proselytisers of AGW are conceding that they have insufficient data to support their psuedo-scientific beliefs:
Since 2006, the BBC has relentlessly promoted the global warming orthodoxy as a pressure group in its own right.  In covering the latest twists of this story on his blog, Montford cites another odd BBC programme, Earth Reporters: Sea Change, funded by Unesco, which was like an adulatory commercial for the scientists who push alarm about the impact of global warming on the oceans, via the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.  The scientific adviser for the programme was the same Dr Smith who organised that 2006 seminar, and whose website lists a string of other BBC programmes he has worked on.
The irony is, however, that just as the BBC adopted its new hard line on climate change, in the real world the story was beginning to shift.  Ever more searching questions have come to be asked about the supposed “consensus” on man-made warming, and the BBC’s coverage has come to look ever more one-sidedly absurd.
Last week, even Richard Black, another BBC proselytiser for man-made warming, was gloomily having to reveal the conclusion of a new IPCC report: that, over the next few decades, “climate change signals are expected to be relatively small compared to natural climate variabilty”.  In plain English, that means the great scare story is over.  What a shame.  But at what a price.
UPDATE I (21 November):  see also Bishop Hill’s “Mail on Sunday on the Beeb”; UPDATE II (22 November), but the article (linked therein) by David Rose has been removed.  UPDATE III (22 November):  the article has been restored—but, just in case, here it is:
BBC’s Mr Climate Change accepted £15,000 in grants from university rocked by global warming scandal

A senior BBC journalist accepted £15,000 in grants from the university at the heart of the ‘Climategate’ scandal—and later went on to cover the story without declaring an interest to viewers.
Roger Harrabin, the BBC’s ‘environment analyst’, used the money from the University of East Anglia’s Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research to fund an ‘ad hoc’ partnership he ran with a friend.
Mr Harrabin, an influential figure who both broadcasts and advises other BBC journalists, later reported extensively about Climategate.  The scandal erupted two years ago when emails were leaked from the Tyndall Centre’s sister department, the Climatic Research Unit at the same university.
The leaks left the scientific community in disarray after claims that key data was manipulated in the run-up to a major climate change summit.
An [incompetent, biassed, inadequate] official inquiry later found that although there had been no scientific fraud [based on insufficient evidence and a lack of investigative thoroughness], there was “a consistent pattern of failing to display the proper degree of openness, both on the part of CRU scientists and on the part of the UEA.”
In none of Mr Harrabin’s reports on the subject were the grants that he and his friend Dr Joe Smith had received from UEA ever mentioned.  However, BBC insiders claim that the use to which the money was put—annual Real World seminars for top BBC executives on issues including climate change—had a significant impact on the Corporation’s output.
“The seminars organised by Roger and his friend were part of a process which has effectively stifled all debate within the BBC about man-made global warming,” said one senior journalist.  “As far as the high-ups are concerned, the science is settled.”
Last night, Mr Harrabin insisted he does not derive any personal financial benefit from the grants and that far from making him more sympathetic to UEA, the sponsorship—of which the BBC had been aware—“made me doubly determined to investigate Climategate.  If I had been misled by UEA I wanted to be among the first to know.”
In none of Mr Harrabin’s reports on the subject were the grants that he and his friend Dr Joe Smith had received from UEA ever mentioned.
He added:  “The funding from the Tyndall Centre came long before Climategate.  And I was forensic in exposing it.  So any suggestion that I was biassed or soft on Climategate in any way is completely untrue as demonstrated by my reporting.
“I was praised by the world’s leading climate sceptics for my reporting.  Those seminars—for which I received no personal gain—included contributions from sceptics.”
He said his report into the subsequent inquiry into Climategate, led by Lord Oxburgh, was praised for its “forensic impartiality”.
Disclosure of the payments to Mr Harrabin’s private partnership comes in the wake of a damning report last week by the BBC Trust Editorial Standards Committee.
It revealed ‘sponsored’ documentaries on environmental issues, whose production costs had been met by ‘non-commercial’ bodies such as the UN Environmental Programme, have been shown frequently on the BBC World news channel without viewers being made properly aware of their funding.
Trust investigators discovered that of a sample of sixty sponsored programmes broadcast between February and July this year, a total of fifteen breached the BBC’s editorial guidelines.
The investigators said some of the breaches involved direct conflicts of interests—with the funders being the subjects of the programmes they were paying for—and that others failed to observe BBC rules on telling viewers where the programme budget had come from.
Two films in the latter category, part of BBC World’s Earth Reporters series, had Dr Smith as their chief scientific adviser.  He is a climate change specialist at the Open University.
He said yesterday that the Open University sought to ensure that the programmes they co-produced were factually accurate, but beyond the usual formally agreed acknowledgement of the university, programme credits were the “concern of the BBC”.  Dr Smith agreed with the Trust’s conclusions on the matter.
However, it is clear that sponsored programmes about the environment of the type the Trust now deplores have been made on a huge scale for years.
Almost all the £1.4 million annual income of TVE, the production company behind the Earth Reporters series, comes from non-commercial bodies, including the EU, UN agencies and campaign groups such as WWF, which co-founded the company twenty-seven years ago.  Jenny Richards, TVE’s deputy chief executive, said the firm had made “hundreds” of programmes for the BBC, and described the Trust’s criticisms as a “slap on the wrist”.
The Trust has demanded sweeping changes to the BBC’s commissioning process, and the Corporation has agreed that from now on programmes sponsored by non-commercial bodies will be forbidden.  Those from independent production companies will be scrutinised for possible conflicts of interest.
A Trust spokeswoman said:  “Anything that affects the trust of viewers is a serious matter and the steps we are taking to prevent it from happening in future are very clear.”
Mr Harrabin’s partnership with Dr Smith—the Cambridge Media Environment Programme (CMEP)—began in 1996.  That was when Mr Harrabin spent a sabbatical at Cambridge University, where Dr Smith was working at the time.
From then until 2009 they organised their seminars, which Dr Smith described as an ‘ad hoc’ arrangement.  “It was just a light touch thing.  These were occasional seminars held in an academic environment that brought a diverse mix of research, business and policy people together with media people,” he said.
While Dr Smith was paid less than £5,000 for organising each conference, Mr Harrabin did not benefit financially. Dr Smith added that people with dissenting views on climate change were represented, and the purpose of the events was to encourage reflective thinking away from the pressure of deadlines.
His own opinion, which he sets out on his website, is that “everyday human activity—moving, eating, keeping warm or cool —is gently stoking a slow-boil apocalypse”. He calls climate change “one of the challenges of the age” and urges the world to take radical action.  A Freedom of Information Act disclosure obtained by Andrew Montford, who writes the climate-change blog Bishop Hill, reveals that the Tyndall Centre provided £5,000 a year for three years from 2002.
The centre’s newsletter said then it was giving CMEP the money“ because we share its commitment to the effective communication of climate change information to increase knowledge and inspire discussion and debate in society”.
In addition to the Tyndall Centre, the CMEP received funding from energy giant BG, HSBC, Vivendi, the Bowring Trust and the WWF.
Dr Smith has acted as a scientific consultant to dozens of other BBC programmes, including high-profile documentaries about climate change fronted by Sir David Attenborough.
He was also involved in the BBC2 drama series Burn Up, in which a central character argued that the world had only five years to save itself before global warming became irreversible.
A BBC spokeswoman said: “The BBC is aware of the funding arrangements for the Real World seminars.  They have been considered against our editorial guidelines and raised no issues about impartiality for the BBC or its output.”

18 November, 2011

Just Another Billion or So

At Big Government, Wynton Hall describes how Robert Kennedy, Jr. just happened to obtain a $1.4 thousand million bailout for his company:
It’s just one more in a string of eye-opening revelations by investigative journalist and Breitbart editor Peter Schweizer in his explosive new book, Throw Them All Out.
The details of how BrightSource managed to land its ten-figure taxpayer bailout have yet to emerge fully.  However, one clue might be found in the person of Sanjay Wagle.
Wagle was one of the principals in Kennedy’s firm who raised money for Barack Obama’s 2008 presidential campaign. When Obama won the White House, Wagle was installed at the Department of Energy (DOE), advising on energy grants.
Still, judging from the lack of concern from most of the media, we may safely assume that the Obama administration, apart from this one excess, has been spending taxpayers’ funds prudently and with the utmost fiscal responsibility and transparent, fiduciary competence.

UPDATE:  see also Bryan Preston’s take, at PJ Media:
Obama’s administration handed Kennedy’s company, BrightSource, $1.4 billion in loans.  That’s almost three times the amount loaned to Solyndra.  Both companies had big Democrats deeply involved.  Both companies went under.  Who pays for that?  According to Obama and other liberals, the rich don’t pay their fair share of taxes.  So the middle class is paying for RFK Jr. to get that loan.

02 November, 2011

Matt Ridley on Pseudo-Science

Bishop Hill provides the text of Matt Ridley’s excellent speech, “Scientific heresy”, a lecture at the Royal Society of Arts in Edinburgh:
Does it matter?  Suppose I am right that much of what passes for mainstream climate science is now infested with pseudoscience, buttressed by a bad case of confirmation-bias, reliant on wishful thinking, given a free pass by biased reporting and dogmatically intolerant of dissent.  So what?
After all there’s pseudoscience and confirmation-bias among the climate heretics too.
Well, here’s why it matters.  The alarmists have been handed power over our lives; the heretics have not.  Remember, Britain’s unilateral Climate Act is officially expected to cost the hard-pressed UK economy £18.3 billion a year for the next 39 years and achieve an unmeasurably small change in carbon dioxide levels.
At least sceptics do not cover the hills of Scotland with useless, expensive, duke-subsidising wind turbines whose manufacture causes pollution in Inner Mongolia and which kill rare raptors such as this griffon vulture.
At least crop circle believers cannot almost double your electricity bills and increase fuel poverty while driving jobs to Asia, to support their fetish.
At least creationists have not persuaded the BBC that balanced reporting is no longer necessary.
At least homæopaths have not made expensive condensing boilers, which shut down in cold weather, compulsory, as John Prescott did in 2005.
At least astrologers have not driven millions of people into real hunger, perhaps killing 192,000 last year according to one conservative estimate, by diverting 5% of the world’s grain crop into motor fuel.
That’s why it matters.  We’ve been asked to take some very painful cures.  So we need to be sure the patient has a brain tumour rather than a nosebleed.
UPDATE:  meanwhile, at Real Science, Steve Goddard notes that the world must have ended eleven years ago: 
San Jose Mercury News (CA) - June 30, 1989 – 3F General News
GRIM FORECAST
A senior environmental official at the United Nations, Noel Brown, says entire nations could be wiped off the face of the earth by rising sea levels if global warming is not reversed by the year 2000.  Coastal flooding and crop failures would create an exodus of “eco-refugees,” threatening political chaos, said Brown, director of the New York office of the U.N. Environment Program.  He said governments have a 10-year window of opportunity to solve the greenhouse effect...

25 October, 2011

How Muddy Thinking Sticks

In the latest issue of The Skeptic, (31, 3. September 2011), you may read “How Mud Sticks”, by Dr Ullrich Ecker and Dr Stephan Lewandowsky, wherein the learned authors, and professors of psychology, explain that sceptics are more likely to distinguish “the right from the wrong”—whereby they mean, I suppose, distinguishing fact from fiction—; but, unfortunately, when considering the pseudo-scientific conjecture of anthropogenic global warming, both professors are credulously silly.  Ullrich and Lewandowsky use the political terminology “climate change” when, apparently, they refer to anthropogenic global warming; they hypocritically calumniate former Senator Nick Minchin, a true sceptic of AGW (who correctly asserts that the climate has always changed and always will), as a “denier”; and the supposed academics cite Wikipedia as a source whilst uncritically accepting, seemingly, the bogus claims in Merchants of Doubt by the mendacious Oreskes and Conway:
learning that some prominent climate change deniers, such as outgoing Australian Senator Minchin, also long denied the adverse health effects of tobacco21,22 may make [meaning, I expect, “ought to make”] people more suspicious of all their claims involving scientific issues.
In general, a healthy sense of skepticism makes you better at telling the right from the wrong.  [...]
[end notes] 21. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nick_ Minchin
22. Oreskes, N., & Conway, A. M. (2010). Merchants of Doubt. New York: Bloomsbury Press.
It is true that “a healthy sense of skepticism” generally helps educated people to distinguish objective facts from politically correct fiction, so it is a pity that Ecker and Lewandowsky refuse to analyse the multitudinous fraudulent, far-fetched, self-serving claims of awarmists with appropriate scepticism.  Furthermore, Ecker and Lewandowsky stupidly, deceptively and dishonestly conflate Minchin’s reasonable, legitimate, scientific doubts (such as whether passive smoking might cause various ill effects) with the tobacco industry’s alleged refusal to acknowledge the undoubted toxicity of tobacco.

UPDATE I:  see “Upset intellectuals”, by John Izzard, at Quadrant Online:
What has happened to some of our unhappy intellectuals is that they are now confronted with a new concept, science-politics.  Science-politics follows closely on the heels of history-politics, which was first spotted in academia in the writings by historians of Aboriginal history.  The basic premise of history-politics was that you can force political change upon a country, and its citizens, by re-jigging history to achieve a desired political outcome.  That is, create a feeling of guilt, then work on the guilt factor to demand change.  It works a treat.  It really does. 
Science-politics surfaced when climate-theory scientists suddenly found, after the release of the first IPCC report, that they were under serious questioning from not only fellow scientists, but members of the general public.  Suddenly the cosy world of the IPCC was exposed to scrutiny, both in the media and by the newly emerging internet community.  Hitherto unimaginable amounts of information were suddenly available to the public about, not only the scientific methods used by the IPCC, but also the rather unsavoury political games that they were playing with the public’s mind.  And they were fairly adroit at character assassination of their dissenting scientific colleagues. 
Australians (79%) had become very suspicious, perhaps when they first learnt that the IPCC only accepted scientific research and reports from scientists who totally agreed with their climate-science.  They then became further concerned when they read of the University of East Anglia climate unit’s jigging of figures and tweaking computer models to fit in with their theories.  But the most curious mistake the “most qualified and knowledgeable” made, was the too-clever-by-far spin that the science “was settled”.  It wasn’t.  It isn’t!
UPDATE II:  see also Stuart Schneiderman on “the Global Warming Cult”, Lisa Friedman, in Scientific American, on “New Research Casts Doubt on Doomsday Water Shortage Predictions”, Marc Morano’s “Scientific case for man-made global warming fears is dead”, Michael Barone’s “Cult of Global Warming Is Losing Influence”, and John O’Sullivan’s “Skeptic Economist in Critical Assessment of Climate Consensus”.

UPDATE III:  from the Dissenting Report of Senators Nick Minchin and Sue Knowles from The Tobacco Industry and the Costs of Tobacco-Related Illness: Report of the Senate Community Affairs References Committee (December, 1995):
Senator Minchin believes that:
Proponents of bans on smoking in the workplace and other public places base their demands on the premise that tobacco in the air—passive smoking—can harm the health of non-smokers.
These claims are not yet conclusively proved.  For example, it has been estimated that in a workplace that permits smoking, it would take between 260 and 1000 hours for a non-smoking worker to be exposed to the nicotine equivalent of a single cigarette.  A worker might be exposed to between 2 and 4 cigarette equivalents in a full year of work.  It has also been estimated that it would take 300 hours of dining in a restaurant that permits smoking, to be exposed to the nicotine equivalent of one cigarette.  [p. 121]
UPDATE IV:  see also Climate Nonconformist’s “Has he even listened to a skeptic?”

UPDATE V:  meanwhile, in the world of scientific publishing (involving the vaunted but flawed peer-review process so beloved of awarmists), read Richard Van Noorden’s “Science publishing: The trouble with retractions”:
This week, some 27,000 freshly published research articles will pour into the Web of Science, Thomson Reuters’ vast online database of scientific publications.  Almost all of these papers will stay there forever, a fixed contribution to the research literature.  But 200 or so will eventually be flagged with a note of alteration such as a correction.  And a handful—maybe five or six—will one day receive science’s ultimate post-publication punishment:  retraction, the official declaration that a paper is so flawed that it must be withdrawn from the literature.
In comments to the above article, Prof. Brian J. Morris adds:
What does one do when the journal appears complicit in the publication of seriously flawed data when one has provided a scathing critique as an invited peer reviewer for the manuscript?  This happened to me earlier this year for a journal with a good reputation and impact factor of over 5.  The paper in question was scientifically flawed, grossly distorted the literature in the field clearly to progress the authors' stated personal agenda.  The statistical analyses were erroneous.  I recommended rejection, but after being sent a revised version in which virtually none of my extensive list of initial criticisms was addressed I stated that extensive corrections were required.  When it then appeared on-line in advance I offered to write an editorial and then submitted one for publication so that readers would be made aware of the serious flaws.  Two months later the journal rejected this and offered to consider it as a Letter to the Editor.  I have been waiting 4 months and still no decision.  The paper in question should be retracted.  I can understand that the Editors might be embarrassed that this paper slipped through in to print.  But their failure to take any steps to date to address the situation that has arisen now leads to an impression of complicity.
UPDATE VI (26 October):  of course, if Ecker and Lewandowsky really believed what they wrote they might consider that learning of the bias and duplicity of the IPCC’s alleged experts ought to “make people more suspicious of all their claims involving scientific issues”.  They would do well to read Donna Laframboise’s The Delinquent Teenager Who Was Mistaken for the World’s Top Climate Expert.


UPDATE VII (26 October):  see Simon’s “Environmental activism taints research” at Australian Climate Madness.

UPDATE VIII (29 October):  for more on The Delinquent Teenager, see London Book Review here and here.

UPDATE IX (29 October):  Luboš Motl, fittingly, describes awarmists as numerologists (when, perhaps, they’re not working on phrenological or astrological charts).

12 October, 2011

Not a Conspiracy

In “Chief scientist Ian Chubb pans conspiracists” by Andrew Trounson of The Australian, we read that Australia’s chief scientist, Ian Chubb, whilst claiming that believing in conspiracies is silly, believes in a vast anti-scientific conspiracy.
Science was “under siege”, he told a meeting of the National Tertiary Education Union, while ridiculing theories of a “hush-hush” plot in mainstream science.
“(They) would have you believe that climate scientists, whose work supports the evidence that human activity is contributing to climate change, are cheats and frauds and worse,” Professor Chubb said.  [...]
“For many in the media and politics and for the plethora of so-called commentators, undermining science is becoming an increasingly popular pastime,” he said.  [...]
Professor Chubb also criticised scientists who blamed conspiracy theories to explain why their work might be rejected by scientific peer review.
“I cannot believe that there is a global conspiracy of establishment scientists successfully suppressing results contrary to the mainstream and we don’t know about it.  Somebody, somewhere would have the evidence – which would be more than a rejected manuscript,” he said.  [...]
“In an environment where we are asked to take action in the face of imperfect knowledge, it is perhaps not surprising that some science is coming under renewed attack.  It has happened before and doubtless will happen again.
“We saw it with tobacco, initially with the hole in the ozone layer and we see it with climate science,” he said.
The “Climate-gate” e-mails shew that “the team” of misanthracist alarmists secretly plot to harm real scientific progress by foisting their own perverted, pseudo-scientific conjecture upon the world for their own selfish benefit, but it’s not a conspiracy.
Those alarmist, deceitful frauds make furtive machinations and devise plots to defame and to destroy their opponents, but it’s not a conspiracy.  Their intrigues involve employing underhanded methods in order to gain grants, wealth, prizes and acclaim which would otherwise go to better, more deserving researchers, but it’s not a conspiracy.  They lie and cheat and pervert the peer-review process with malice aforethought, and thereby undermine real scientific endeavour, but it’s not a conspiracy.
We may be grateful that Australia has a Chief Scientist who can tell us when a wicked, self-serving conspiracy is not a conspiracy. 

UPDATE I:  The Joint Select Committee on Australia’s Clean Energy Future Legislation has published only a minority of submissions they received and—completely coincidentally, surely—mainly those which support the inept Government’s plan to tax some industrial emissions of carbon dioxide, but that is not corruption and not at all a conspiracy.
 

UPDATE II:  see also “It Is Not a Conspiracy”.

UPDATE III:  see too Jeff Id’s “Divide and Rule” at the Air Vent.

26 September, 2011

12 September, 2011

Climate Change Is Real, of Course

Given our knowledge of physics, it is not just true, but trivially and obviously true that humans cause the climate to change.
But then so do ants cause climate change, and their arch rivals the aardvarks.  As do yellow perch and their meals the nightcrawlers.  Any species that moves or engages in respiration, or in eructation after a good meal, changes the climate.
It would be impossible for them not to.  Why?  Because any move through the atmosphere changes its state, just as any exchange of gases changes the state, and any change of state of the atmosphere is a change of climate.  And that is that. Humans, ants, and every other damn creature cause the climate to change.
The only question is how much?  A worm wiggling across the surface of a sidewalk after a rainstorm is not moving fast, and thus not causing large changes of state of the atmosphere.  But it’s not as simple as that: the birds who dive bomb the worms cause larger changes, changes that would not have taken place had the worms not been there.
And when the worm begins to rot after you squish it, its dissolving body changes the chemical composition of the atmosphere, and changes it in a different way than if it were processed through the gut of a robin.
Don’t scoff!  We read that the biomass of worms outweighs that of humans.  Worms are unimaginably important critters, aerating—get it?—soil, feeding fish, and crawling trillions of miles.  How can we say authoritatively the exact effect worms have on climate?  We cannot, not exactly; but perhaps we can approximate it.  [...]
Humans and worms do cause the weather to change, even cause it to change measurably; thus they also cause the average of the weather—the climate—to change measurably.  For instance, your author lives on a small island upon which is dumped a great, tangled mass of concrete, through which scurry motorized vehicles, rats, cockroaches, and even people.  These static and movable objects cause great changes in the weather, and thus in its average.
Humans, on the island and off, also pump various gases and other effluvia into the atmosphere.  These gases also cause changes in the weather, thus climate.  So much is indisputable.
What is disputable is how much.  We can ask—it is an intelligible question—what the weather (thus climate) would be like on the small island given the concrete, vermin, and people were removed.  We might cobble together a mixed physical-statistical model which gives an answer.  But the answer won’t necessarily be the right answer.  And we’ll never be able to tell if it’s right or wrong because we’ll never be able to shift all that stuff off the isle to check.  [...]

02 September, 2011

Tangled Webs

At The Resilient Earth, in “Climate Science’s Tangled Web”, Doug L. Hoffman reports that bogus reports of global warming from alleged scientists continue:
Recent days have seen a number of announcements about our changing climate.  As it turns out, Arctic ice is rebounding, sea levels are dropping and things just are not going according to the IPCC's plan for catastrophic global warming.  Faced with reversal after reversal, it might seem logical for mainstream climate scientists to admit that they are wrong, that global warming is not taking place at a breakneck pace, but this has not happened.  Instead, climate change apologists are weaving a tangled web of excuses—hot is cold, wet is dry, up is down.  No matter what happens to the world we live in, the root cause according to the doomsayers is always the same:  it’s always global warming’s fault.
Sea level rise due to global warming has been a topic of intense debate for years.  While the minuscule rise of the world's oceans has been fairly steady for most of the last 20 years, every once in a while sea levels do something unexpected.  In the past two decades global sea levels increased at a rate of roughly 0.12 inches a year, compared to 0.07 inches from 1961 to 2003, according to satellite data.  A recent study of sea levels, as measured by tide gauges, suggested the rate of ocean rise has declined in the past decade around Australia and New Zealand.
See also  Bill Muehlenberg, at Quadrant Online, on “The growing desperation of the climate alarmists”:
You can always tell when real science has long ago given way to hysteria and agenda setting when the arguments being dragged out become more and more bizarre.  Less and less science is offered, and instead we get all sorts of blatant moonbattery.
We have had several prime examples of this lately.  Consider a major player in all this, Al Gore.  He has gotten so desperate to push his whacko agenda that he is now saying that climate change skeptics are basically in the same camp as racists.
Just as we had to fight the ugly racists in the past, Gore says we need to do the same with those ugly climate change skeptics today.  And we are supposed to embrace the alarmists as the epitome of rationality and science?  Sorry Al, but I don’t have enough faith to be a true believer like you are.
Then we have the case of an Australian true believer who has actually said we can link climate change to mental illness!  Yes you heard me right.  An ABC report puts it this way: “A report has been released that draws a direct link between inaction on climate change and long-term social and mental health problems.  [...]
I suppose it is only a matter of time now before scientists will be telling us that climate change is responsible for migraines, impotence, and the common cold.  Indeed, they will soon inform us that the London riots were due to climate change.
 A recent song:
Climate Change Is Responsible for All the Things That Have Ever Gone Wrong

Polar bears numbers may be on the rise,
we know what to blame whenever one dies.
See rivers inundate each sun-baked plain
for global warming brings more and less rain;
farms will be barren or covered with mud
as all crops suffer from a drought or flood;
more dearth, devastation, much more death—
we poison the world with every breath.
    Climate change is responsible for
    all the things that have ever gone wrong.
We may see fewer storms or maybe more
then thirsty nations will be stirred to war.
Give me liberty or give me the rope
for man has nothing when he has no hope
    Climate change is responsible for
    all the things that have ever gone wrong.
You’ll hear the eloquent wind in the trees:
“our weather will spread more nasty disease.”
Across the mountains see a want of snow;
and early this morning I stubbed my toe.


    Climate change is responsible for
    all the things that have ever gone wrong:–
    woeful standards in atrocious schools,
    everyone in a ship of fools,
    the London riots, the Gillard coup,
    and man’s first disobedience too,
    the fire at Pharos, all modern wars,
    the rise and fall of the dinosaurs,
    the wall street crashes, and poor TV—
    all the bad things that ever can be.
    Climate change is responsible for

    all the things that have ever gone wrong.