———————————————————————————————————————————————

25 February, 2012

Prof. Richard S. Lindzen on Climate Science

The Campaign to Repeal the Climate Change Act:  Prof. Richard Lindzen’s Seminar, “Global Warming: How to Approach the science”, held at the House of Commons Committee Rooms Westminster, London on 22 February, 2012.  A PDF of the presentation is available (from Bishop Hill) hence.






























































UPDATE
(28 February)
:  video, in two parts, of Prof. Lindzen’s presentation can be seen here.

24 February, 2012

Climate Commission “Conversation”

On Wednesday, 22 February, a “conversation” on climate change was held in Hobart to discuss the associated impacts and opportunities for Tasmania.  Well, we were told we’d have a conversation; instead, a high school lecture was given on how we are corrupting the planet and how we need a magical tax on “carbon” to save us (even though without carbon dioxide we wouldn’t breathe) and that the planet would thank us therefor.
The four main speakers who were spouting this pseudo-scientific bullshit were Prof. Tim Flannery, Prof. Will Steffen, Prof. Lesley Hughes and some slow, boring economist, Mr. Roger Beale.
After the presenter, Kim Millar, had finished licking everyone’s arse clean, Tim Flannery started by pointing out that they were completely independent and were not under any political influence.  He then went on to say just how bad it would be if the temperature rose half a degree over the next decade.
When Flannery had had his fill he introduced Will Steffen, who continued the scare story, saying that the polar caps will melt and cause the sea-level around Tasmania to rise 3mm each year; he seemed to think that the rise would continue at a rate of 3mm a year, for a century, with no fluctuation at all.
After Steffen, the egg-looking man, Beale, presented a school-level power-point display which, like the other offerings, depicted nasty buildings letting out steam from their chimneys, and went on to claim—incorrectly—that CO2 is the leading, most important greenhouse gas, and that “the planet knows how to release heat” and that it has been doing it since the beginning and seems to know what it is doing.
The last contribution of the introductory speeches was given by Lesley Hughes who said that, as the temperature increases, we will have less salmon; as she said this, she referred to the movie “Finding Nemo”, and claimed that the salmon would be unable to live in 1% warmer water.  She then displayed another, cute card, saying that the broad-toothed mouse (a species which survived previous warm periods and the last Ice Age, and is still around today) would be unable to cope with another 0.5% increase in temperature, and die out.  She added that more extreme weather would occur, and that people wouldn’t be able to survive a 45ºC maximum temperature nearly every day; in effect, she was saying that cities of Arabia are already uninhabitable.
The presenter then announced question time and joked about killing people by way of ejector seats if they did not comply with the rules that questions be brief and non-political; nonetheless, all the questions, except two, were either long, about politics, or just complete Dorothy Dixers about how Greens are such great people, that we must save the planet, and that we would all be happy to pay a high “carbon” tax.
The presenter failed to call on me to ask a question, though I raised my arm for over half a weary hour, but I managed to approach Prof. Flannery after the forum had concluded.  I asked, “What if you’re wrong about AGW?”

Flannery responded, “What’s AGW?”
I said, “Anthropogenic global warming; you know, man-made.”
He replied, “Oh, yeah.  If we’re wrong, at the very least, we’ll have cleaner air because carbon dioxide and burning coal is bad, and we’ll have better energy.  If we’re right we’ll have all the other benefits.”
I asked when Brisbane would run out of water and Flannery stated, “Within the next couple of years.”
A conversation (coming from the Latin for “back and forth”), refers to an exchange of ideas, but the Climate Commission’s “conversation” consisted of our listening to lectures and lengthy, unnecessary answers and grandstanding questions from pious believers.
On Wednesday, 22 February, I survived an hour and a half of complete pseudo-scientific bullshit with only a few decent biscuits at the end as a slight compensation.

(Also posted on Alfred’s Review.)

23 February, 2012

An Inevitable Outcome

At the Climate Commision’s Hobart public propaganda session—misnamed a “conversation”—, one of the commissioners, and demonstrated liar, Prof. Will Steffen, asserted that the sea-level around Tasmania will rise 3.2 mm a year for every year over the next century, creating a scary scenario of a total rise of 30 cm by the end of the century—that’s one foot!—leading to higher tides, increased flooding and the ruination of infrastructure.  Steffen, of course, contrary to the evidence, assumes that the rate of any rise of sea-level will continue at the exact rate which awarmists claim is occurring now.
So, since Commissioner Steffen claims that the seas around Tasmania will rise consistently by over 30 cm a century, and since he ignores inconvenient data such as the undoubted fact that there is a finite amount of terrestrial ice which might melt, what will happen after a millennium?  Obviously, the seas will assuredly rise 30,000 cm, or three hundred metres; after ten millennia, therefore, with the waters’ having risen three kilometres, Tasmania will be completely flooded!
If the rise of sea-level continue at the same rate over a million years then the seas around Tasmania will most certainly rise 300 km!  If the rise of sea-level continue at the same rate over ten thousand million years then the Tasmanian seas will surely rise 3,000,000 km!
If the rise of sea-level continue at the same rate over 500,000,000,000 years then the seas around Tasmania will rise 150,000,000 km, which will snuff out THE SUN!  So, unless we reduce carbon emissions by imposing a ruinous tax on some important industries, and if the rate of seal-level rise remain constant, then within five hundred thousand million years the seas around Tasmania will annihilate the sun—and then we’ll really be doomed!
(The Climate Commission’s own specious report, The Critical Decade: Tasmanian Impacts and Opportunities, has the claim that, by the end of the century, “global sea levels are projected to increase by at least 0.5 m and perhaps by as much as 1.1 m.”  So, maybe, the earth’s waters might extinguish the sun within only 150,000,000,000 years or so.)

22 February, 2012

Tasmania’s Littoral Doom

The Climate Commission, the Government’s mystagogic office for the propagation of the faith in Global Warmism, has released its latest mendaciously misleading, and ill written report, The Critical Decade: Tasmanian Impacts and Opportunities:
Tasmania is particularly vulnerable to sea-level rise because most Tasmanians live close to the coast.  For instance, in some places a 50 cm sea-level rise could [could!] result in a present 1-in-100 year event becoming an annual or more frequent event by the end of the century. [p. 2]
Global average sea level has risen by about 20 cm since the late 1800s, and at an increasing rate since the early 1990s.  Sea levels have also risen around Tasmania, although at a slightly slower rate than the global average.  Over the next century, global sea levels are projected to increase by at least 0.5 m and perhaps [perhaps!] by as much as 1.1 m.
Tasmanian communities are vulnerable to the impacts of sea-level rise because 75% of the population lives in coastal areas (DCC, 2009).  An estimated 8,700–11,600 houses, with a value of up to $3.3 billion, may be at risk of flooding towards the end of this century [...], assuming a sea level rise of 1.1 m which is at the higher end of projections (DCC, 2009).
The impacts of sea-level rise are felt most acutely during severe storm events.  Even small rises in sea-level lead to very large increases in the frequency of coastal flooding when combined with a storm surge and high tide [what, just the one surge and high tide?].  In some locations in Tasmania, a half metre sea-level rise would [would?] result in a present 1-in-100 year event becoming an annual or more frequent event by the end of the century (Church, 2008; Hunter 2011).  [p. 4]
The cover’s image: giant whirligigs obliterate all of Tasmania’s islands.

It is true that many Tasmanians “live close to the coast”, and I am one of them—the beach, for me, is only a stone’s throw away, littorally—; but my dwelling is several metres above sea-level so, though I am part of the “75% of the population [which] lives in coastal areas”, I will surely be quite safe.  In fact, even if the oceans did rise by half a metre, and even if governments neglected to undertake simple, prudent measures such as building seawalls, the majority of Tasmanians would be safe because, though the commission avoids mentioning the fact, most Tasmanians who live near the sea also live well above sea-level.
The projections of any rise of sea-level are based on an incorrect assumption—from either incompetent or willful ignorance of the latest research—that the slight, modern rise of sea-levels will continue; however, as Stuart Rintoul revealed last year, despite our Government’s hyperbolic claims, such rises are decelerating:
Mr [Phil] Watson’s analysis of the four longest continuous Australian and New Zealand records is consistent with the findings of US researchers Robert Dean and James Houston, who analysed monthly averaged records for 57 tide gauges, covering periods of 60 to 156 years.
The US research concluded there was “no evidence to support positive acceleration over the 20th century as suggested by the IPCC, global climate change models and some researchers”. 
Houston and Dean demonstrate that “the current sea-level trend of about 1.7 mm/y will produce a rise of about [19 cm] over 110 years from 1990 to 2100.”  For aught we know, of course, sea-levels may yet descend just as average global temperatures may decline in future decades.
The commissioner of the Climate Commission, the very silly Prof. Tim Flannery foresaw that currently flooded areas would never again see rain but our Earth would soon be revealed to be a living, physical manifestation of Gaia, an earth-mother goddess of the Ancient Greeks.  The inept Climate Commission’s ridiculously contrived, pseudo-scientific report on the conjectured effect of supposed global warming on Tasmania has even less value than its fatheaded commissioner’s far-fetched and hysterical prognostications.